Buffy the Vampire Slayer – Best Episodes

So, this blog is all about, as the title would suggest, finding, and appreciating all things exquisitely savory in this world. This is not by any means limited to food and drink – there is also music, film, language, art – and of course, television. What greater joy than discovering a truly well-written series to sink one’s teeth into. Hours – years of entertainment, even.

Speaking of language – I was musing over the structure of the word ‘yummy.’ LETTER-U-DOUBLE CONSONANT-Y. So many yummy things fit this pattern – Curry! Sunny! Puppy! Funny! Of course, there’s also fussy, muggy and bully… but never mind that. The word I’m pondering at the moment, you guessed it (probably less so because you have psychic powers, and more because you read the title of this post) – is Buffy.

Ah, Buffy the Vampire Slayer. If you haven’t watched the show, it’s probably for one of the following reasons: A) You’re not into the fantasy/horror genre. B) You believe it’s a cheesy schlockfest made for kids (although, admittedly, a couple of early episodes may have solidified that idea in your mind), or C) You are sick to death of every single geek in the universe, or at least on the interwebs, going on and on and on about how friggin’ great Buffy is. Enough already. You’re not going to watch it out of principle. I really did know 4 people who fit into category C – although 3 of them have since caved, and are now fervent Buffy acolytes. (One of them, side note, was the owner of the video store where I used to work. He used to make fun of my fellow employee, Jon and me for loving Buffy so much. When he finally sat down and watched the series – devoured, I should say, he promptly moved it from the ‘Television’ section of the store to ‘Classics.’)


Well, if you haven’t seen it, you’re only hurting yourself, I say. Heh, but I jest. I’m really not going to tell anyone that they have to watch anything. Not even… what’s a good broccoli* film? Shoah, say. I’m not going to tell you you have to watch Shoah. If you think Buffy (or Shoah) is not for you, it’s not for you. My friend Ann – as big a sci-fi/fantasy afficianado as anyone I know, was fairly ‘meh’ about Buffy – but she loved the spinoff, Angel, so we still talk and stuff.

So then, if you haven’t yet seen the TV show Buffy the Vampire Slayer, I suggest you go out and rent it (or stream it, or whatever you kids are doing these days), and come back to this post after you’ve finished season 7 – because SPOILER ALERT! applies to everything after this paragraph.

Okay…here goes, The Best Episodes of Buffy, one per season. (I’m excluding season finales, as they are almost always the best episodes.)

Season 1

“Puppet Show”

Season 1 is a half-season, and unquestionably the weakest of the 7 – but there is still some great fun to be had. I’m torn between  “Angel,” and “Puppet Show” for best episode. “Nightmares” is also a contender, but logic of the premise starts to fray at the edges if you think about it too hard. “Angel” is pivotal, but I’m going to go with “Puppet Show.” What? Okay, hear me out. Joss Whedon pulls off something extraordinary here, and it sets the stage for many of his future endeavors. Mr. Whedon thinks big. He comes up with  plot twists and set pieces that should never work, ideas that other auteurs would dismiss out of hand, and he pulls them off. His ability to take something absurd and hilarious and ground it with emotional truth, and some genuinely scary moments, is unparalleled. So, in “Puppet Show,” you not only have a sentient ventriloquist dummy – Buffy’s right – it’s super creepy (anyone who’s seen Magic can attest to that) – but he turns out to be a good guy. Plus, there’s that moment when Giles almost gets his brain sliced open, which makes me squeak every time.

Pair With: A glass of water, gargled. 


Season 2


Okay, one season in, and this just got really hard. This is where the show officially stepped up, and became what it was meant to be – horror as analogy for teenage life – with great characters, and more than a little dash of humor. It starts out with a bang -with quite possibly the best Buffy premiere episode of any season (“When She Was Bad”), and just gets better from there. The introduction of Spike and Drusilla – vast improvements over the previous season’s villain, Willow stepping out of her Xander-obsessed shell into Oz’s waiting arms, Cordelia becoming a little more human and falling for Xander, and, of course, the relationship between Angel and Buffy, getting steamier and steamier. Really, did any of us see where that was going? Suprise/Innocence” (I’m cheating – but I consider them a 2-part episode) – the best of the season, left me almost as devastated as Buffy when Angel lost his soul. And oh, what a villain he became. He easily terrorized Buffy more than any other enemy on the show, at any point. Heartbreaking. Epic.

Pair With: Birthday cake (but don’t blow out the candles).


Season 3


It’s tempting, again, to pick the mid-season, two part, deal-changing episodes as the best of the season. Faith goes over to the dark side! – Well-done, shocking. Similarly, we only get one taste of Spike this whole season, in “Lover’s Walk,” and it sure is good to see him again. Plus, that’s the episode that exposes Willow and Xander’s affair, and leaves Cordelia wounded in more ways than one. But I’m going with “Doppelgangland,”  because sometimes Buffy’s at its best when it’s just a blast. The setup for this episode happens in “The Wish,” in which an alternate universe is created, one where Xander and Willow are vampires. That episode is uber-dark, and savvy Mr. Whedon sensed that we all wanted to see more of Vamp Willow, in a less dire setting. So she comes to our universe (well, Buffy’s), and confusion, terror, and quite a lot of humor ensues. Buffy was unique at the time, as a show that actually harkened back to things said and done in seasons past, and foreshadowed things to come – seasons in advance. I know that seems like common sense these days, but really, it was a rarity at the time. So our Willow observes about Vamp Willow:

Willow: It’s horrible! That’s me as a vampire? I’m so evil and… skanky. And I think I’m kinda gay.
Buffy: Willow, just remember, a vampire’s personality has nothing to do with the person it was.
Angel: Well, actually…

Boy did they follow up on that one.

Pair With: A banana and/or a glass of Cline Ancient Vines Mourvedre (depending on which Willow you’re toasting).


Season 4


There are almost no clunkers in this season – so again, it seemed like a difficult choice, but in the end it was a no-brainer. Here’s Whedon and company thinking outside of the box once more – an episode where no one can speak? Gutsy. This works so well for two reasons. Wait. Three. A) The terrific music.  B) The episode is, on a deeper level, about the way we communicate, or the way we don’t. Friends talking over one another, potential lovers not knowing what to say, etc. and C) The villains are really, really scary. The fantastic mime and character actor Doug Jones (Pan’s Labyrinth, Hellboy), plays the leader of the ‘Gentlemen’ – creatures from the most nightmarish fairy tale imaginable, who cut out the hearts of their victims with a tiny little scalpel and grinning aplomb. Contenders for the creepiest Buffy baddies ever.

Pair With: A scotch, in solidarity with terrified Olivia.


Season 5

“The Body”

For some folks, Season 5 is where Buffy starts to get great. For me (and for a majority of fans, I think), it marks the end of an era. Sure, it still was better than most TV… But seasons 2, 3 and 4 were so strong – and I look at 5, and am not at all conflicted about which episode is the best. It’s got to be “The Body.” Ugh. I know, right? Easily the saddest episode of any season. Also the only episode that is straight drama, with nothing supernatural in it until the very end. Buffy and her friends are dealing with Joyce’s unexpected death – and the fact that she’s killed by an aneurism, and not a vampire or demon, make it somehow worse. This episode is a punch to the gut – and also a beautifully-shot, very honest portrayal of what it’s like to lose someone. Oh, those heart-wrenching silences.

Pair With: A soothing cup of tea and a lot of Kleenex.


Season 6

“Once More With Feeling”

I know, I know… predictable. But it is really one of my all time favorite episodes, period. In a season with so much darkness, the musical, and the ensuing episode, “Tabula Rasa,” give us a little respite from all the angst. Buffy wasn’t the first TV show to do a musical episode, but I still think it stands as the best of its kind. The songs are clever, a prelude to Whedon’s crazy-popular “Dr. Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog,” but the surprise here is how pivotal the plot is… and all the major emotional revelations that occur within the lines of the songs. We get a hint that Xander and Anya just might not be meant for one another, in the number “I’ll Never Tell.” Tara discovers that Willow is messing with her memory, and Willow’s inability to see just how wrong that is warns us of much darker times to come. And, of course, Buffy reveals the ultimate truth, the one she never would have disclosed had it not been for a powerful spell – that in bringing her back to life, her friends had not saved her from untold torment, but instead had rent her from heaven. Oh. And that kiss. That kiss was a long time coming.


Pair With: (So many choices!) A cruller, couscous, waffles, stinky cheeses, hossenfeffer, and lots and lots of mustard.


Season 7


Despite the mostly annoying Potentials mucking up the works, there are some strong episodes this season. “Lies My Parents Told to Me” is terrific, but I didn’t choose it, because Giles’s betrayal of Buffy (along with Willow’s and Xander’s later in the season) really grates my cheese. (I’ll no doubt get into that in some future blog.) I also really love “Help,” and the actress playing Cassie is pretty phenomenal. (Although can we call for moratorium on precognitive characters being named ‘Cassandra?’)  I can’t imagine many actors pulling off that combination of sadness, resignation, wry humor, and forgiveness.  It’s difficult to choose between “Storyteller,” Andrew’s video log episode, and “Selfless.” But, call it a coin flip, I’m going with “Selfless.”  It’s really strong – a tough episode, and Emma Caulfield as Anya does some of her best dramatic work of the series. The only sour note is the song.  I love the idea of flashing back to the day the dancing demon came to town, and showing us another musical number, but this one isn’t all that good, frankly. However, we get to see Anya’s history (including a cheeky, Bergman-esque medieval sequence, featuring the always fun Abraham Benrubi), and the conversation Buffy, Willow and Xander have about having to kill Anya is pretty incredible. Buffy gets the final word with ” I killed Angel. Do you even remember that? I would’ve given up everything I had to be with him – I loved him more than I will ever love anything in this life and I put a sword through his heart because I had to.” Ohhhhhh…SNAP.

Pair With: MEAD!


What are your favorite episodes, one per season, of Buffy (excluding finales)?  Do share!



* Not to be confused with a Broccoli film, e.g. From Russia With Love.


13 thoughts on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer – Best Episodes

  1. Rachel and I have just started Season 7, and just watched Selfless. So bittersweet. I hate when relationships end. Damn it, people growing!

  2. The funniest thing about Chris was how he originally tried to ban us from talking about Buffy on Wednesday mornings, and then he had to reluctantly admit how good it was.

    My only changes would be: A. 7th season is worse than 1st season. And B. My 3rd season pick would have been “The Zeppo” and I would have paired it with a beer, a manly, manly beer.

  3. Love that one too, Jon – it will most certainly appear in a future post about the funniest of all Buffy eps. You know, now that I think about it, Doppelgangland and The Zeppo are sort of female and male fraternal twin episodes…

  4. Just because I love the show so much and figure it’s worth expanding on your (very fine) blog review, I will take you up on your challenge to list 1 favorite from each season. I will exclude any that you have named (which are most certainly the best of the series…”The Body”? Hell.) I will not play your little game of excluding season finales because I don’t wanna. So there, too. In fact, I’ll start with one. How do you like them apples?
    Season 1: Prophecy Girl
    The hard part about turning people on to Buffy is that they (logically) want to start at the beginning and watch every episode. But because the show took so long to find its legs (I would argue that “Surprise/Innocence” in season 2 is the hook), some might give up before ever making it to the good stuff. So I have, what I like to call my “prescription for addiction”..a 12 episode viewing list which covers seasons 1 & 2. It has yet to fail. It is controversial, however, in that it STARTS with the final episode of season 1.
    First of all, this was the first episode of the series to be written AND directed by Joss. I believe that it was this episode where the entire production collectively went “OH…I see what we’re going for here”. It begins with, essentially, a re-introduction of all the major characters. Because Jenny Calendar is being brought into the group, a lot of the necessary mythology is explained. It pretty succinctly explains everything one needs to get out of season 1 without forcing a person to watch “Teacher’s Pet”.
    Season 2: “I Only Have Eyes For You”
    This episode blows me away..almost as much as “Surprise/Innocence”. What appears to be an episodic story, unrelated to the series arc, turns out to be absolutely pivotal in the most unexpected way. (Spoiler) Possessed by ghosts and being forced to replay a tragic scenario provides Buffy with the opportunity to have the conversation she needs to have with Angel, in order to do what she needs to do. It is smart and the twist is unexpected and well executed.
    Season 3: “Band Candy”
    I chose this one because it’s super fun. Principal Snyder telling Buffy she drives like a spaz, Giles as an anarchic punk, Joyce and Buffy’s role reversal…all great. But one of the things I love is when Giles & Joyce are listening to Cream (on vinyl) in Giles’ apartment…a moment that is referenced quite poignantly 2 seasons later in “The Body”
    Season 4: “Restless”
    An obvious choice, as it makes most “favorite episode” lists, but it really is quite remarkable. Season 4 was disjointed. Most of the familiar locations (the library & the Summers home) were not to be featured…Angel, Faith, Cordelia and Wes had all moved on. It was a little like…first year of college. Home wasn’t home anymore, but neither was your new environment. Not yet. Plus, Reilly was dull, Adam wasn’t a particularly awesome villain…the best aspects of the season were one-off episodes such as “Hush” and “Superstar”. But “Restless” is unique within the series in that it was a finale that wasn’t about tying up the season (that had been taken care of the episode before), but instead, explored the primary characters to their core, and essentially set up what was to be their emotional journeys for the next 2 seasons. All done in the form of a tone poem.
    Season 5: “I Was Made to Love You”
    There’s no question that “The Body” is the best episode of this season, and next to “Once More With Feeling”, possibly the series. “The Gift” is, of course, the moving conclusion, but this episode deserves some love. It’s significant in that it addresses Spike’s misguided affections for Buffy (and perhaps shows clearly just how misguided it is), it introduces a future villain in Warren, and despite him seeming like a relatively harmless nerd, highlights his detachment, lack of empathy and his deceit, which manifest themselves in much more dire ways later on. The episode, again, seems like a one-off…one based on a silly premise, but it’s actually rather touching, introduces elements which will be focused on later, and then there’s the last scene…
    Season 6: “Seeing Red”
    A difficult episode to watch…one of the more emotionally wrenching of the series. This episode is at the heart of the season 6 story arc. Everything has been leading up to this episode…The fact that Buffy had been fooling herself to think that a toothless Spike was anything other than an evil thing. Spike’s fantasy that he was capable of love, and realizing it only after a horrifying act even he thought himself incapable of. Xander dealing with Anya’s having moved on, Willow and Tara, newly reconciled, separated in a very final way. Each character pushed to extremes of pain, setting up what might be the best season finale of the series.
    Season 7: “Same Time, Same Place”
    I was originally going to go with “Conversations with Dead People” which is an exceptional episode (though flawed by what should have been an appearance by Tara). But instead, I picked this one. Having taken Willow to such extremes at the end of season 6, they couldn’t bring her back into the fold without consequence. This episode wonderfully shows the love that these characters feel for one another, despite mistrust, misgivings, insecurities. One of the overall themes of the show is that of a family of one’s creation. Now, there have been many times throughout the series where the core characters have been at odds…sometimes really letting one another down. But at the heart of it, they truly are a family. And in this episode, one sees the faith that they ultimately have in one another. Also, one of the creepiest demons since The Gentlemen.
    So there you go, m’dear. I don’t disagree with any of your picks…in fact I don’t think I would argue any of my selections over any of the ones you cite. But like I say, it’s more to review and we love Buffy and God bless America and all that stuff. -B

  5. Fantastic, Brian. (And if I were choosing finales, I’d definitely choose “Prophecy Girl” as well)… I absolutely love, love, love, “I Only Have Eyes For You” as well. The only place we really diverge is “Restless.” And “Band Candy” is very much going to show up in the Funniest Ep. post – coming soon!

  6. Pingback: Small Screen Gems | Finding the Yummy

  7. Hmmm…tough call. Best of season, that’s not a finale (cause the finales of seasons 2, 3, and 4 represent Buffy in it’s finest form). So quickly (and subject to change as the mood takes me):
    Season one: Never Kill A Boy On The First Date.
    Season two: Passion. Epic.
    Season three: Helpless (but this was the hardest season to chose just one…Band Candy, The Wish, and The Zeppo totally rock). Helpless was just plain scary.
    Season four: hmmm…This Year’s Girl/Who Are You? I love watching the Buffy/Faith dynamic play out.
    Season five: Tough…Fool For Love over The Body, but not by much. Either way, I cry.
    Season six: Tabula Rasa (OMWF is off limits for me, it’s kind of like the finales).
    Season seven: hmmmm…Conversations with Dead People.
    So,there you go!

    And my all time top five are: Restless, Passion, The Body, Fool for Love, Becoming 1 & 2.

  8. Golly, I guess I do! Imagine that…
    I love the music as much as the episodes (and sometimes I like episodes because the music is so great!). When I was under employed I decided to track down all the music from all 7 seasons for my iPod. So far I have 108. Makes a fine playlist. The favorites list is again subject to change. Because I’m still missing a few.
    Season 1: Strong by Velvet Chain, Inconsolable by Jonatha Brooke, It Doesn’t Matter by Alison Krause
    Season two: Spoon by Cibo Matto, 1000 Nights by Nickel, Never An Easy Way by Morcheeba
    Season three: Fire Escape by Fastball , Chinese Burn by Curve, Virgin State of Mind by K’s Choice .
    Season four: Memory of a Free Festival by David Bowie, Nothing but You by Kim Ferron , Sweet Charlotte Rose by Headland
    Season five: Bohemian Like You by The Dandy Warhols, Tales of Brave Ulysses by Cream
    Season six: Everybody Got Their Something by Nikki Costa, Goodbye to You by Michelle Branch, That Kind of Love by Alison Krause
    Season seven: Blue by Angie Hart, Still Life by Patty Medina , Mr. Spock by Nerf Herder.
    At least now when my clarinet teacher asks me what have I been listening to lately, I don’t have to feel so embarrassed…
    And you? What are your favorites?

  9. Pingback: The Best of Buffy – Happy Anniversary To Ms. Summers « The L. Palmer Chronicles

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s